Restaurant Review: Vito’s Midtown Pizza – Wilmington
Rating: 9 out of 10
Wilmington, NC — Vito’s Midtown Pizza located at 2305 College Road, right at the Long Leaf Hills Drive intersection, continues to operate as a takeout‑forward shop with a small dine‑in area, but what they offer, they keep tidy. The outside of the building is clean and well‑kept, with a neat storefront and maintained exterior that reflects the restaurant’s steady, consistent operation. Vito’s also operates a convenient drive‑up pickup window, making it easy to grab pre‑placed orders without leaving the car. a simple but genuinely helpful feature during busy hours. And oh, the smell when you walk in – that unmistakable New York pizza aroma that hits you instantly and lets you know you’re in the right place.
Inside, the seating area is limited but orderly. Tables are clean, the space is uncluttered, and the windows and door glass are spotless. It’s a comfortable place to wait for your order or grab a quick bite, even if the setup leans more toward pickup than lingering meals. Staff were friendly and welcoming throughout the visit, keeping the counter service moving smoothly.
A most recent stop landed us two pies – a Meat Lover and a White Pizza and both came out in true Vito’s fashion: super‑hot, balanced, and baked to simple perfection. The thin crust folds just right, giving that classic New York bend without losing its crisp edge. Pricing remains reasonable for the Wilmington market, with most specialty pies landing in the at the mid $20 buck range and classic options coming in a bit lower. Portions are generous, and the quality matches the price point. It stands out as the best pizza pie we’ve had in the Wilmington area, consistently well‑made and true to the style they promise.
Vito’s remains a reliable choice for takeout, drive‑up pickup, or a quick sit‑down, delivering quality that keeps regulars coming back.
Check ‘um out next time you cruise College Street, located at the light at Long Leaf Hills Drive.
© 2026 BCDollarSaver.com. All rights reserved.
